Top 10 Eateries in Martha's Vineyard, MA
Sitting just seven miles off the shores of Massachusetts, the island of Martha’s Vineyard feels like a peaceful retreat far from city life. With activities year-round, the island is full of local shops, interesting architecture, beautiful beaches, and, of course, dining options.
Many of the eateries in Martha's Vineyard are known for their fresh-caught seafood creations, but you’ll find something to match most tastes here. Here is a list of the top Martha's Vineyard restaurant options for you to consider on your next visit:
1. Lookout Tavern
8 Seaview Ave, Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02557
Voted the best sushi in the Vineyard 12 years in a row, Lookout Tavern offers seafood and an open harbor dining experience. The sushi is the star of the show, with each flavor carefully plated to be both tasty and artistic.
Of course, they also serve up delicious burgers for those who prefer land-based fare, but seafood is often the star of the show. A raw oyster and shrimp bar, award-winning lobster rolls, and an extensive cocktail list make dining here a treat. Arrive early, as Lookout Tavern doesn’t accept reservations.
2. Midnight Mediterranean
6 Circuit Ave. Extension, Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02557
If you’re craving a taste of Greece or Italy, then Midnight Mediterranean will meet your needs well. You can enjoy lamb gyros, gyro bowls, kababs, and a wide variety of salads and wraps. Like most Martha’s Vineyard restaurants, there is seafood on the menu as well, such as seasonal black sea bass.
The ambiance here is casual, and many guests will get their food to go to enjoy on the beach. If you do dine in, you may enjoy live music during your visit. This restaurant is fairly new, occupying the space once occupied by Midnight Taco, both of which have the same owners.
3. Midnight Taco
7 Circuit Avenue Extension, Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02557
The first thing you’ll notice about your plate at Midnight Taco is the color. While each dish is full of flavor, the chefs here worked carefully to ensure each one is also full of vibrant color from fresh produce.
The meat is marinated to perfection, and the salsas and sauces are made fresh in-house. Locally caught seafood makes the most delicious tacos, or you can choose chicken, steak, or pork if you prefer. Whenever possible, the team here uses locally-sourced ingredients to lock in the flavor.
4. The Pawnee House
20 Kennebec Ave H, Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02557
Sitting in a portion of the historic grand Victorian hotel that shared its name, The Pawnee House is more than just a restaurant. It’s a piece of Martha’s Vineyard’s history. The menu features flavors from many parts of the world, with a focus on comfort foods.
With gluten-free and vegan options, including desserts, The Pawnee House works for most diners. The seasonal Sunday Brunch menu is a favorite with locals and visitors alike, and it even comes with a special brunch cocktail menu to perfectly pair with the menu options.
5. The Barn Bowl & Bistro
13 Uncas Ave., Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02557
At The Barn, you can enjoy a delicious lunch or dinner and a round of bowling, all in one place. The menu here is not what you’d expect from a bowling destination, as it’s quite extensive and high-class.
Dine on dishes like Brazilian picanha steak or shrimp and lobster pasta, then finish your meal with a crème brulee cheesecake. Portions are generous, and the flavors are full at this bistro and bar.
6. Among the Flowers
17 Mayhew Ln,, Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02539
Open for breakfast and lunch, Among the Flowers is a hidden gem among eateries in Martha's Vineyard. This charming destination is surrounded by colorful flowers, and you can eat outdoors while the blooms give off their fragrances. The meals here are healthy and made from local ingredients, but they’re also packed with flavor.
The café has been in the area for nearly five decades, yet it remains less traveled, and therefore less crowded, than other dining options. You’ll enjoy the quieter atmosphere while dining on tasty dishes when you visit.
7. The Seafood Shanty
31 Dock St,Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02539
Located directly on Edgartown Harbor, Seafood Shanty has two separate floors for diners. Try the rooftop outdoor dining option, or enjoy your meal inside on the first floor. No matter which you choose, the harbor will be the backdrop to your meal.
This distinctive restaurant has been serving food to Martha’s Vineyard residents and guests for over six decades, and it continues to deliver decadent meals. The star of the meal here is seafood, but you’ll also find burrito bowls, salads, and chicken wraps. There’s an extensive bar menu and multiple sushi options here as well.
8. Martha’s Vineyard Chowder Company
9 Oak Bluffs AveOak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02557
Visiting Martha’s Vineyard without diving into a bowl of seafood chowder should be illegal, but you can remedy this with a visit to this Martha's Vineyard restaurant. While the restaurant has some of the island’s best chowder, it also has an extensive sushi and raw bar.
If you have non-seafood eaters in your group, there are several options that will fit their needs as well.
9. Bettini Restaurant
131 N Water St Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02539
Located within the Harbor View Hotel, Bettini Restaurant is an upscale dining option serving contemporary American dishes. It boasts excellent views from its windows, yet provides elegant indoor seating. Considered island-to-table, Bettini serves fresh-caught seafood alongside homemade pastas, tender steaks, and duck fat potatoes or truffle fries on the side.
Many dishes are available vegan or gluten-free for those who need them. After choosing your entree, check out the extensive wine list from the award-winning Wine Room at Bettini.
10. The Black Dog Tavern
20 Beach Street Extension, Vineyard Haven, Martha's Vineyard, MA 02568
With its rustic décor, The Black Dog Tavern points back to its initial days as one of the first restaurants in the area. Today, it continues to serve good food harborside to visitors in Martha’s Vineyard.
This Martha’s Vineyard restaurant is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and it offers daily specials that make every visit unique. Consider dining in the Tavern, which offers an outdoor patio overlooking Vineyard Haven Harbor, or inside the historic building.
As you consider your options for your next Martha’s Vineyard trip, the right research will make your trip a success. Our partners at Point B Realty Vacation Rentals can serve as your local guides to help you plan your vacation. They also have an extensive list of luxury rental homes in Martha's Vineyard for you to consider.
