3 Amazing Beach House Rentals in Anna Maria Island, FL

Published: March 23, 2025

Anna Maria Island, located on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is a rare beauty known for its stunning beaches, crystal-clear waters, and serene ambiance. The island boasts over 7 miles of pristine shoreline, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, and water sports. The weather is consistently pleasant, with gentle sea breezes and plenty of sunshine; the consistent warm climate makes this a year-round paradise.

Famous for its charming, small-town feel, Anna Maria Island offers a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of larger tourist spots. Visitors can enjoy the rich culture of the island, which is characterized by colorful beach cottages, local seafood restaurants, and art galleries.

To experience the best of Anna Maria Island, there’s no better option than staying with Mainsail Vacation Rentals. Mainsail Vacation Rentals is the premier provider of vacation homes on the island, offering an exceptional selection of properties that cater to all tastes and group sizes. Not only do they offer luxury beach houses on Anna Maria Island, but they also provide expert local insights and personalized service, ensuring that your vacation is nothing short of perfect.

With a beach house, you’ll have direct access to the island’s stunning shores and the freedom to create your own schedule. To give you a taste of some of the amazing vacation rentals that they provide, here are five incredible beach houses on Anna Maria Island:

High Tide

Chic modern dining area featuring a terrazzo-style table, white tulip chairs, and colorful napkins that pop against a geometric wallpaper backdrop.

Up to 6 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

High Tide is one of the absolute best family-friendly beach rentals in Anna Maria Island, FL! The vacation rental is just steps away from the beach, offering easy access to the island's beautiful shores. Guests can enjoy the communal heated pool, outdoor patio, and BBQ grill, making it perfect for outdoor meals and lounging. Guests will also love the outdoor shower, designated luggage storage, and direct beach access.

For added convenience, the home provides beach equipment like a cooler, ensuring a fun day by the water. Located near local shops and dining, there are plenty of nearby activities for families to enjoy, including Manatee Beach Park. High Tide is a space where memorable vacation experiences are made!

Top Amenities:

Communal Heated Pool
Outdoor Shower
Direct Beach Access

Check Availability & Pricing Here

Vitamin Sea

Modern and playful living space featuring a curved white sofa, bold orange accent chairs, and geometric wallpaper with a mounted flat-screen TV.

Up to 4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Vitamin Sea is a colorful and stylish vacation rental perfect for that family and small group getaway you have been putting off for far too long. Guests can enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, cozy living room, and amenities such as a communal heated pool and a BBQ grill, ideal for relaxing after a day at the beach. Beach equipment, such as a cooler, is provided for your convenience.

Nearby, you’ll find plenty of activities including local dining, shopping, and outdoor adventures like paddleboarding and biking. Whether you're soaking up the sun or exploring the island, this home provides the perfect base for your Anna Maria Island getaway.

Top Amenities:

Communal Heated Pool
Outdoor Shower
Direct Beach Access

Check Availability & Pricing Here

Mainsail Beach Inn

Cozy and sunlit coastal den featuring two armchairs, a flat-screen TV, and French doors leading to a private patio. A stack of striped pool towels adds a splash of beachy charm to the light, airy decor and warm wood floors.

Up to 6 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 2.5 Bathrooms

Although technically a condo, Mainsail Beach Inn is a dream to stay in, offering guests a spacious and elegant retreat just steps from the beach. This beautifully renovated condo features a fully equipped gourmet kitchen with marble countertops and stainless steel appliances, perfect for gathering together, creating meals and memories. Guests can enjoy peek-a-boo views of the Gulf of Mexico from the expansive deck.

On-site amenities include a heated resort-style pool, hot tub, poolside grill, and private beach lounge chairs with umbrellas. The property also provides beach equipment like chairs, umbrellas, kayaks, and bicycles for a fun-filled day at the beach or exploring the area. With its central location, guests can easily access nearby shops, dining, and attractions. A perfect beach day is everyday at Mainsail Beach Inn.

Top Amenities:

Included Beach Gear
Communal Hot Tub/Heated Pool
Direct Beach Access

Check Availability & Pricing Here

It’s clear that Anna Maria Island is the perfect destination for those seeking a blend of natural beauty, tranquility, and local charm. These beach house rentals in Florida provide the perfect blend of comfort and convenience, offering spacious accommodations, exceptional service and private amenities to enhance your stay. Mainsail Vacation Rentals ensures that every aspect of your stay is meticulously taken care of, from offering personalized recommendations to ensuring your contentment and satisfaction.

When it comes to experiencing the island at its best, there’s no better way to enjoy this paradise than by staying in one of Mainsail Vacation Rentals’s stunning beach houses for rent. Prepare for the feel of the sand under your feet and the sun on your skin, your perfect beach house getaway is just a click away!